Capital Allocation Perspectives (Part I: Employees)
Employees prioritize pay, benefits, and career growth – These desires can conflict with shareholder returns – Effective capital allocation requires deliberate trade-offs.
CAPITAL ALLOCATION PERSPECTIVES (PART I: EMPLOYEES)
Capital allocation decisions have far-reaching consequences for all stakeholders in a business. Key stakeholders include employees, executive leadership and board members, customers, and the broader community, in addition to the company’s shareholders.
Management teams have four simple choices when allocating excess capital: internal investment, M&A, share buybacks, or dividends. While economic returns may be similar across these options, each of these decisions creates different downstream effects for the business’s stakeholders.
These downstream effects add complexity to capital allocation decisions, often resulting in suboptimal choices from a shareholder’s perspective. In this series, we will examine capital allocation decisions from the perspective of each stakeholder to understand why and how capital allocation choices go awry.
The Employee Perspective
Employees are the lifeblood of every business. Motivated employees satisfy customers, work efficiently, and, through cumulative effort, create the economic production that drives business profit. Unmotivated employees, not reaching their full potential, create a drag on the business’s productivity.
Leading corporate cultures are increasingly recognized as critical business assets, often creating differentiation or moats for businesses that lead on this front. Decentralized operations are encouraged for their ability to empower employees. Flexible hours, luxury office space, corporate retreats, and other non-cash benefits are used to attract and retain top talent.
But all these costs are a choice. From a shareholder’s perspective, any investment in a business’s employees must create a tangible return, and this return is difficult to quantify. As a result, employees and shareholders naturally differ in their capital allocation preferences.
Employee Expenses
Any costs of employment above bare-minimum operational standards are a choice, but creating and sustaining a motivated, empowered employee base requires investment. Management can choose to motivate, retain, and empower employees, and the expense to do so runs through a company’s P&L.
Building a leading corporate culture requires allocating time to team building that could be spent driving the business. Decentralized operations are, on paper, inefficient compared with centralized operations. Employee perks have a real monetary cost, whether directly as benefits or indirectly via lower employee productivity.
From an employee’s perspective, any dollar invested in their well-being provides value. To the extent employees provide excess value to the business in return, management has allocated capital wisely.
Growth Capex
Leading talent wants the opportunity to learn, grow, and develop. This opportunity is often tied to the growth of a business. Growing firms create opportunities for employees to be promoted, launch new products, or work in new geographies.
This growth is funded by internal capex. When the return on this capex is estimated purely through a financial lens, ancillary benefits to employees are often ignored. Companies that are too stringent with capex may stagnate and lost talent. Most employees enjoy the opportunity to work with the latest technology available as opposed to continually repairing outdated equipment.
Employees and shareholders are often at odds when evaluating internal capex spend. To a shareholder, every dollar of excess capex comes out of shareholder returns. To employees, this spending creates tangible benefits beyond any economic return.
M&A
Like internal growth capex, spending on M&A can create opportunities for employees to grow in their careers. On the other hand, synergy-driven M&A may put employees at risk of downsizing. In this situation, shareholders and employees are rarely aligned.
Shareholders, employees, and management teams should agree that every M&A decision must be weighed from each stakeholder’s perspective. Economically rational deals are often derailed by cultural mismatches, integration disruptions, and declines in employee morale. Any M&A action must be financially attractive enough to account for each of these risks.
Crisis Management
At some point in their lifecycle, all businesses will be challenged. A company’s approach to surviving these challenges highlights the different incentives provided to employees versus shareholders.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, many businesses saw demand for their products and services evaporate. Without demand to satisfy, what need was there for employees? Across the globe, businesses were faced with difficult choices as to how to allocate their dwindling capital. Many laid off staff outright; others retained their workers at the expense of shareholder returns.
In less extreme scenarios, management teams are still faced with the choice of whether to invest in employees. Corporate restructuring is an ever-present phenomenon. From the perspective of an employee, downsizing is never a benefit. From a shareholder’s perspective, efficient operations are essential for both economic returns and a business’s survival in globally competitive markets.
Shareholder Returns
Returning capital to shareholders via dividends and buybacks is typically at odds with employee preferences. Any returned capital leaves the business, meaning it is not spent on employee benefits or growth opportunities.
Unfortunately, employee ownership of shares only begins to address this problem. While share ownership ostensibly aligns incentives, it is nearly impossible to give employees sufficient ownership to outweigh their preference for internal investment.
A modest dividend increase is nowhere near as beneficial to an employee as a promotion. And essentially no amount of return can compensate for losing a job due to an M&A-driven restructuring. When incentives cannot be aligned, management teams and shareholders must strive to achieve a fair compromise, understanding that not everyone’s desires will be fully met.
The Long-Term View
Understanding the benefits of capital allocation decisions from an employee’s perspective provides management and shareholders with real insight into how to allocate capital.
Over the long-term, motivated and aligned employees are essential to a business. Developing this type of employee base is valuable to a company’s long-term performance. Capital allocation decisions should therefore consider the impact on employees, even at the expense of short-term returns.
Management teams must have the courage to invest internally, potentially at the risk of missing market expectations, to protect their valuable employees. Shareholders must take an empathetic view of these investments and balance short-term returns with long-term value creation.



